Federal safety regulators are checking whether Waymo's fix for illegally passing stopped school buses did what the company said it would. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration opened a "recall query" in a November 6 filing, through its Office of Defects Investigation, to "assess the adequacy of the remedy," after concluding that the majority of reported incidents occurred after Waymo deployed the software update intended to stop the behavior.
The fix, the recall, and what came after
The timeline is the problem. Waymo completed a software update for all affected vehicles on November 17, 2025, and issued a voluntary recall a month later, in mid-December. Passing a stopped school bus with red lights flashing and the stop arm extended is illegal in all 50 states, and the two agencies involved see different evidence. The initial federal investigation opened in October 2025 after footage showed a Waymo robotaxi crossing perpendicularly in front of a stopped, unloading school bus in Atlanta: the vehicle approached from the bus's right side, turned left around the front of the bus, and continued down the street. Austin Independent School District officials reported at least five incidents in a letter to the agency, and more were documented in the months that followed in both cities where Waymo runs public service. The National Transportation Safety Board, the country's independent safety investigator, found another passing incident in mid-January, several weeks after the supposed fix, and it is running its own investigation alongside NHTSA's.
Waymo spokesperson Dana Gallagher said the company has "made significant improvements to vehicle behavior around school buses" and has received no citations since March 2026, months after the recall. "The Waymo Driver has a clearly demonstrated positive impact on roadway safety," she wrote, adding that once the query arrives the company will respond to it and looks "forward to continuing our engagement on recall processes for AV software that continues to learn and improve."
Austin helped collect the training data anyway
The strangest detail in the government's account comes from Austin. The school district there coordinated a half-day data collection event with Waymo, bringing school buses and stop-arm signals to an empty parking lot so the company could gather information to train its vehicles against the maneuver. That event happened after the software fix and the recall had already been issued, and incidents continued anyway.
Recall queries of this kind have ended in civil penalties before, some reaching tens of millions of dollars for automakers and software developers. The query puts Waymo in the awkward position of having done everything a recall requires, on paper, while the underlying behavior resurfaced anyway. Waymo is expanding internationally in the meantime; its Singapore service will not carry paid riders until 2028, and regulators elsewhere have been equally unwilling to accept "the software improved" as an answer, as the FAA showed when laser strike reports fell 24% and it called 4,470 incidents in a year far too many. Waymo will respond to the query; the question NHTSA is asking is whether the remedy deserves its name.
Source: Wired, TechCrunch