Amazon says it has stopped using nondisclosure agreements with the government agencies it works with on data centers. The sentence is Matt Garman's, in a blog post aimed at the backlash. It is one line in a longer argument that the buildings are good for the towns around them.

TechCrunch's report quotes Erin Brockovich on what she hears first: projects announced after the permits are already in hand, developers who do not call back, and local officials who signed NDAs before the neighbors knew a project was coming. New York has announced a one-year moratorium on permits for large centers. Garman says more than 100 moratoriums are being considered across the country. If they pass, he wrote, the United States would be writing its own losing ticket, with consequences that last generations.

He picked four complaints and answered each

Water is the first. Citing an Amazon report, Garman said direct data-center water use is 0.5% of U.S. industrial water use, far below golf courses and almond farms. TechCrunch notes that Nvidia has said a new cooling design removes nearly all water use inside the hall, and that both claims leave out the water in generating the electricity and in making the chips. Scientists told the piece they need independent counts, because no federal or state rule tells companies how to report the figures.

Electricity is the second. Garman said rates have risen in some states with many centers and fallen, or risen more slowly, in others. Where bills are up, he blamed an old grid that was not expanded before the demand arrived. An independent watchdog, cited in the same story, said data centers were the main cause of a 76% year-over-year price increase on the country's largest grid. Europe has already logged about $42 billion in delayed or cancelled projects. The U.S. argument is the same equipment and a different set of permits.

The Texas permit is 33 million tons

Pollution is the third myth on Garman's list. A planned Amazon center in Texas is permitted to release 33 million tons of carbon dioxide a year, more than any other U.S. power plant, by the comparison in the piece. Garman's reply is that the generators almost never run. "They're idle 99.9% of the time (they run roughly 10 hours per year, mostly for required maintenance testing)." The NAACP is suing SpaceX and xAI over pollution. The fourth item is local benefit. Here he wrote the NDA sentence, and added that over the past three years Amazon has contributed more than $1 billion to U.S. communities where it has a meaningful data-center presence.

The past three years were a different billion

A single quarter of local opposition in the U.S. has already been tallied at $68 billion of blocked projects. Garman's hundred moratoriums are proposals, not that tally. Anthropic's Dario Amodei has called the backlash a crisis of trust. Writer Jasmine Sun's version, quoted by TechCrunch, is what happens when opponents are shown the company's numbers: they say they do not believe them.

The NDA change is the part a town clerk can check. The 0.5% water figure and the 10 hours of generator time are the parts that still depend on Amazon's own accounting. Garman set the 0.5% against golf courses and almond farms, which is his comparison, not a federal table. TechCrunch adds that chip manufacturing and power plants use water the hall itself does not meter. The 76% grid-price jump, from the watchdog, is the electricity claim that does not come from Amazon's blog. New York's moratorium is one year and already announced. The hundred others are still proposals. Brockovich's pattern is the sequence neighbors describe: permit first, announcement second, an NDA already signed. Garman says that last step has stopped.