Sony has cancelled Fairgame$, the competitive heist shooter that Haven Studios announced in 2023, according to a Bloomberg report. The decision followed a large-scale playtest. PlayStation executives Sean Decker and John Doyle told Haven staff in an email that the test showed "strong operational excellence, live ops readiness and community engagement" while "player feedback and retention results were mixed and fell short of the goals we had set." They cited "challenging market conditions in the PVP shooter genre" as the second reason.
The unusual part is what did not follow. Sony said there will be no layoffs tied to the cancellation. Haven, based in Montreal, will instead move its staff onto other PlayStation projects and look for new work of its own. GameSpot confirmed the same terms.
Four years from announcement to nothing
Work on the game predates its reveal. Jade Raymond founded Haven in 2021, months after leaving Google Stadia, and Sony bought the studio outright in 2022 while then-chief Jim Ryan was promising twelve live service games by 2025. Fairgame$ was shown in 2023 as a heist fantasy about robbing the ultra-rich, and then went quiet. GameSpot reports that Haven reworked the concept several times in the past three years and was preparing to re-reveal it under a new name.
Two events marked the slide. Raymond left Haven in 2025, reportedly after an external playtest left PlayStation leadership concerned about how the game was landing. Then the project's own internal test confirmed the pattern. Creative director Mathieu Leduc had described the goal as a PvP game with emergent sandbox play that gave players a fresh story every session. That is the hardest thing to fake in a playtest.
The twelve-game plan is now a list of casualties
Of the live service projects Sony set in motion in that period, most are gone. The plan was twelve titles by 2025. Seven were cancelled before release, which leaves five that either shipped or still exist on a roadmap somewhere. Helldivers 2 became a hit that changed the internal argument, and it also raised the bar for everything else in the portfolio. Concord shipped, was pulled offline in under two weeks and never came back. Marathon is still running but has not met expectations, and the Horizon multiplayer project, Hunters Gathering, was reportedly rebooted after negative playtest feedback.
Haven's survival as a team, rather than a studio with a game, is the part worth watching. Arkane's union has already shown how a parent company can absorb a studio's cost while leaving the staff in place, and the pattern of keeping a Montreal team alive on support work is how publishers avoid a closure announcement. Warren Spector's comparison of executive pay and BioWare layoffs is the other side of the same ledger: cancellations usually get paid for by the people who did not decide them.
What a cancelled game still costs
Sony has not disclosed the budget. A four-year production on a new IP from a studio of Haven's size is the kind of line item that shows up as an impairment charge rather than a press release, and PlayStation has been quietly reversing its live service strategy since Concord. Japan's publishers largely skipped the live service race altogether, which is one reason their headcounts have held up better through the same period.
Decker and Doyle's email is the closest thing to a public post-mortem, and it is thin. "Mixed" retention means players tried it and stopped. The team that built it now reports to other producers, and the next PlayStation live service announcement will be read against a list of seven cancellations and one disaster.