Warren Spector published a follow-up on LinkedIn this week to his earlier post about EA closing BioWare, and this time he attached the compensation. The veteran designer, who spent years at Origin and later ran Junction Point, wrote that he remains unhappy about the closure and then aimed at the people who signed it.

"Tens of thousands of do-ers and makers are out of work and these people think they're worth that kind of compensation?" he wrote. The figures he cited cover EA's 2026 fiscal year, a single twelve-month period, and they are all increases on the year before.

PC Gamer reported the post and the numbers, including one detail that connects the pay to the layoffs more tightly than the argument needs. Chief executive Andrew Wilson received a raise of $8 million on the $30.5 million he was paid in 2025, and part of the award recognised "meeting all milestones for a high-quality launch of Battlefield 6".

The raise was paid for the game that cost the jobs

Battlefield 6 shipped. The studios that built it did not survive intact. Criterion, DICE, Ripple Effect and Motive all lost staff in the months around the launch, and Ridgeline Games, which had been working on a story-driven Battlefield project, was shut down entirely.

That sequence is the substance of Spector's complaint, and it is not really about generosity. A bonus tied to a shipped product is normal governance. The problem is that the same twelve months contain both a completed launch and the destruction of the teams that delivered it, and only one of those outcomes shows up in the pay packet.

His narrower question is sharper than the headline number. "If executives misread the market, over-hire, or make decisions that result in under-funded, over-funded, poorly-marketed games, do they lose sleep, let alone jobs?" Wilson was paid $21 million in a year when shareholders rejected a proposed increase, which suggests the downside for a bad year is a smaller raise.

The rest of the industry is running the same experiment in public. Arkane's union says Microsoft froze hiring and then billed the delay to the studio, and Funcom is cutting staff again while staying with the two games it ships. Different companies, same shape: the cost lands on the people who make the thing.

Shareholder votes on pay almost never fail

The mechanism that is supposed to catch this is the say-on-pay vote, and the numbers say it does not. An analyst report cited by PC Gamer put the failure rate for such proposals at 2.7% in 2019 and 2.6% in 2018. EA's own 2020 vote, when shareholders rejected a proposed increase, was the exception that proved the rule.

A 2.7% failure rate means roughly 97 of every 100 packages pass without a fight, and the ones that fail tend to fail on process rather than size. Boards write the packages, institutional investors vote in blocks, and the comparisons used to justify a number are chosen from a peer group the board also selected.

Spector's post is not a policy proposal. It is a statement that the people who bear the consequences of a decision and the people who make it are, in this industry, two different groups with two different employment contracts. That is a harder problem than a pay cap, and no one has solved it.

What accountability would actually look like

Clawbacks exist on paper. They are used when a company restates its financials, not when a studio closes. A board that wanted to tie pay to employment outcomes would need a metric that survives a good quarter and a bad one, and the honest version of that metric is headcount retained through a launch window, which no compensation committee currently reports.

There is a live comparison in the unionisation wave, where staff are trying to build the leverage that a pay vote does not give them. Microsoft's Xbox division is opening an XP division while cutting studios, which is the sort of decision that looks defensible on a slide and indefensible to the people in the room.

Spector's closing line is the one that will travel: "And if you think this is a discussion about 'sound business decisions' I hope you never get anywhere near running a business." It is an argument about who absorbs the error, and the answer for the last three years has been the same.

The next proxy season is in the spring. Watch whether any large publisher puts a retention metric into its compensation report. None has yet, and that absence is the answer to the question Spector asked.