The proposed class action accusing Micron, Samsung and SK hynix of coordinating a DRAM shortage will proceed, after Judge Noël Wise denied the three companies' motion to have the case dismissed. The defendants had argued the suit was just "a rerun" of the antitrust case brought against the memory industry in 2018, but the court found the plaintiffs have put forward new evidence suggesting collusion, and that what the three are accused of goes beyond fierce but lawful competition. Their conduct, the judge wrote, is "more akin to hawks flying in formation, an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do."
What the plaintiffs allege
The plaintiffs, seventeen individuals and small businesses, point to four parallel moves that they say restricted DRAM supply and produced a shortage in which prices jumped by as much as 500 percent in one year. The timeline they cite begins with simultaneous production cuts from October 2022 to April 2023, followed quickly by what they call a coordinated pivot to HBM, the high-bandwidth memory that AI accelerators consume. Next came the wind-down of DDR4 production announced by all three companies within a span of three months, and a refusal to expand production capacity despite prices that the filing calls "the single most powerful supply signal the DRAM industry has ever produced."
The supporting cast of allegations is longer: stringent customer vetting procedures introduced during the shortage, refusals to sign long-term contracts with DRAM buyers, Micron's decision to shut down the consumer memory brand it sold at retail for decades, and multiple public statements projecting the shortage, alongside the industry's earlier history of price-fixing scandals. Consumers of memory have felt this in retail terms all year, with component costs upending budget builds and memory climbing the materials bill of hardware makers.
The companies' defense and what comes next
The defendants' answer is that everything they did was ordinary business in extraordinary demand. Production cuts, the DDR4 exit, contract refusals and customer vetting are, they argue, rational responses meant to maximize revenue, consistent with each company's independent self-interest. Similar behavior across three firms in a highly concentrated market reflects the fact that all three are "reacting to the same market pressures," not a conspiracy. Judge Wise found the pattern plausible enough to move forward anyway, while being explicit about what the ruling is not: not a judgment on the merits, which still require both sides to present evidence and argument before the court.
The procedural calendar is set. The three companies have until December 7 to respond to the original complaint, and a case management conference to sort out administrative matters is scheduled for January 2027. What changed this week is the posture of the case: the industry's second run through a memory price-fixing claim will not end before it starts, and the discovery that follows will reach the boardrooms of all three manufacturers at a moment when their product is already the most expensive line item in the electronics supply chain, and when every PC maker pricing a holiday lineup is doing the same arithmetic the plaintiffs did.