Cities and states are writing their own robotaxi rules because a federal bill has been stalled for years. The Verge's survey, filed Sunday, says there is no exact count of the local ordinances, and that the patchwork is the outcome the industry spent a decade trying to avoid.
The Verge's account starts the clock in Nevada, which in June 2011 became the first state to legalize self-driving cars on public roads. That was three years before Tesla's Autopilot, five years before Waymo spun out of Google's project, and seven years before the first commercial robotaxi service, which opened in Arizona rather than Nevada. The early statutes were invitations. The new ones are limits. Federal safety standards are still being written. The statute that would set one national rule for autonomous vehicles has sat in Congress for years, and The Verge says that vacancy is why mayors and statehouses are drafting playbooks of their own. Industry leaders had wanted to avoid exactly this stack. As the cars spread, officials keep finding side effects the first welcome did not include, and each finding becomes another ordinance. There is still no census of those local rules. The Verge's reporting treats the absence of a count as the point: the pile is growing faster than anyone is tallying it.
Nevada's 2011 statute was an invitation written before the cars existed. The Verge's account of the years since is that cities which wanted the first fleet are now writing the restrictions, because the cars brought side effects the welcome did not name. Federal regulators are still assembling safety standards. The bill that would replace the local stack with one national rule has been stalled in Congress for years. That stall is the reason a Minneapolis ordinance and a San Diego airport resolution are, for now, the law a robotaxi company actually has to read.
Cities generally cannot set manufacturing standards. They can set the rules of the street, and that is the power they are using. A decade ago, The Verge writes, many of the same governments welcomed the cars, eager to look future-facing. They are back at the drafting table because the cars arrived with consequences the invitations did not name. Federal safety standards are still being scrambled together. The industry wanted one national rulebook. What it has is a stack of local ones, and the stack grows as robotaxis enter another city and officials find another side effect.
Minneapolis wants a person in the car. San Diego wants the airport
Minneapolis is considering an ordinance that would require a human monitor inside an autonomous vehicle, which would ban driverless operation in practice. The San Diego City Council passed a resolution seeking to block Waymo from the airport and to give local agencies direct control over the cars in an emergency. Austin firefighters have objected to the Tesla Cybercab's lack of a steering wheel or pedals, on the argument that a first responder could not take the wheel. New York City, Chicago, and Washington, DC, still have not legalized driverless cars.
The push is not only in Democratic cities. The Verge says the old split, Republicans welcoming the cars and Democrats skeptical, is blurring, and that some Republican-led states are considering tighter rules of their own. In California, several bills would give cities authority to limit fleet size, restrict hours, or enact local permit bans. Separate emergency protocols would require companies to give police and fire departments a physical override or a remote shutoff.
Zoning is the other lever, and the companies are shopping for preemption
A city that cannot write a federal vehicle standard can still refuse a building permit for the lot where the cars are kept, and it can treat an all-night charger as a noise and traffic problem. Culver City explored an emergency moratorium on permits for fleet facilities. Santa Monica used local noise and traffic ordinances against 24-hour charging hubs. Neither step is a ban on the vehicle. Both are bans on the land and the plug the vehicle needs. Waymo says Singapore is next, with paid rides in 2028. The Verge adds London, Tokyo, and Munich to Waymo's list, and Manchester, Madrid, and Dubai to Uber's. The overseas cities are the hedge. The money, The Verge writes, is still in the United States, where costs keep rising.
Waymo, Zoox, and Aurora are prioritizing states whose statutes preempt cities from banning the technology, rather than fighting each local rule in turn. The Autonomous Vehicle Industry Association is pushing Congress for a national preemption that would take the street rules back from city hall. The Verge's point is that the profit, if it comes, is still American: developer costs are rising, and the U.S. is where the companies think the business works. The overseas list is the backup plan if the patchwork gets thick enough to matter. Models that refuse in chat comply when given a robot arm. That was a lab result about a physical tool. The street fight is about who may tell the car to stop.