Recruitment agencies in Britain bill employers a percentage of a new hire's first-year salary, and the spread of AI through the screening stage is forcing them to explain what that percentage pays for. A survey of nearly 300 recruitment professionals in the UK and Ireland by the software firm Bullhorn found that 37 percent said AI had made candidate screening between 26 and 50 percent faster. LinkedIn's 2025 UK report on recruiting found professionals experimenting with generative tools saved an average of 18 percent of their working week.
"If a recruitment agency is simply finding CVs and forwarding them to employers, AI is making that service increasingly difficult to justify," David Berwick, owner of Adria Solutions in Stockport, told CNBC. "Businesses can already automate much of that work themselves."
The large staffing firms are already doing it. Adecco said in February that it had six AI recruitment agents running in the UK and France, and that the UK tools saved around 15 percent of the time spent on recruitment processes. Niki Turner-Harding, the group's senior vice president for the UK and Ireland, said AI has supported more than 2.5 million candidate interactions, about half of them outside normal working hours.
The agents do the admin, not the decision
Adecco's agents do not make hiring decisions. That stays with a human recruiter, and candidates can ask to speak to a person. Turner-Harding's argument is that the technology moves recruiters off administrative work rather than out of the job: "People don't go into recruitment because they love admin. They go into it because they like working with people, solving problems and building relationships."
Matt Collingwood, managing director of VIQU Group in Birmingham, makes the same case with a number attached. VIQU's turnover has grown 47 percent over the past 18 months, partly, he says, because automation freed recruiters to spend time on relationships. "The businesses best placed to succeed will be those that combine technology with strong relationships and genuine expertise," he said, adding that he sees reason for fees to hold or rise if the delivered value grows.
The counter-argument is that the fee was always a proxy for the inefficiency. Paddy Lambros, founder of the AI recruiting platform Dex, said the process is expensive and slow precisely because it is inefficient, and that AI is flooding both sides of the market, with candidates firing off automated applications and employers unable to sift them. That imbalance has been visible for a while: UK graduate employers were fielding about 140 applications per vacancy before these tools were widespread.
Who absorbs the savings
Two predictions sit behind the disagreement. Collingwood expects only about a third of today's agencies to survive the next five years. James Wright, founder of the London executive search firm Velocity Leadership, said AI lets him do work that used to need five people, and singled out the large global search firms, Spencer Stuart, Heidrick and Struggles, Russell Reynolds, Egon Zehnder and Korn Ferry, as the businesses under the most pressure because of their layers of analysts, researchers and consultants.
Others argue that the part AI cannot do becomes more valuable as the rest gets cheap. Chris Stirling, managing director of Stirling Q&R, said software can surface a hundred candidates with "QA" or "regulatory" on their profile in seconds but cannot tell a biotech founder whether someone built a quality system or merely maintained one. "AI is making the easy part of recruiting faster," he said, "which is exactly why the fee now has to be earned on the hard part."
That is the same argument professional services firms are having elsewhere. Deloitte's own forecast has hourly legal work falling from 72 percent of the mix to 44, with the billable hour giving way to fixed and outcome-based pricing. Recruitment is a smaller market with the same structure: a percentage of salary is a price on the outcome, not the effort, which is why it survives automation better than an hourly rate.
What to watch in the fee line
The number to track is not the share of agencies that close. It is the fee percentage itself, which has sat near 15 to 25 percent of first-year salary for permanent placements in the UK for years. If Adecco and its peers keep reporting time saved without cutting prices, the savings are being captured by the agencies. If clients start demanding success-based pricing on the hard part, the fee line moves.
Turner-Harding's framing suggests the industry intends to sell the second outcome. Whether buyers accept it depends on a comparison they can now run themselves, because the screening step they used to pay for is the step their own tools do.