The European Commission published a draft Digital Fairness Act last week, and the games industry's reaction has been loudest from the people who read the text closely. The proposal targets paid-for virtual currencies, pay-to-win mechanics and pay-to-progress systems. On paper it protects children from the worst of free-to-play. In practice, as an analysis in GamesIndustry.biz sets out, it reaches into basic design decisions that European studios make every day.
The core of the problem is Article 14. Companies selling virtual currency would have to show its value in real money, not only when a player tops up but at the moment the currency is spent. The provision covers secondary currencies too, the gems and coins that players acquire indirectly rather than with a card.
Why a price tag in euros breaks a game
Displaying a real-currency equivalent sounds like a labelling rule. Applied inside a game it becomes something stranger. In a fantasy setting, a shopkeeper would have to quote a sword in euros. Games that let players earn currency through play would need a way to price a mixed balance of bought and earned coins, and no obvious method exists.
The analysis also flags a legal tail. If virtual currency is treated as holding real-world value, then a ban, a server shutdown or a transfer between players starts to look like confiscation, compensation or a taxable trade. None of that is written in the draft. All of it could follow from accepting the premise that a paid-for coin has a price after purchase.
Pay-to-win, defined narrowly
The draft prohibits pay-to-win for children outright. Its definition covers purchases that are necessary, or presented as necessary, for progress or success. That leaves room: an item that helps a great deal without being required still falls outside the definition if a player can succeed through grinding instead.
Pay-to-progress gets the same treatment as pay-to-win, and this is the part with the widest reach. Read literally, the category could cover buying the rest of a game after a free trial, or a paid expansion. The line between an expansion and an unlock is one the industry has never had to draw in law.
Penalties are steep. Fines run to 6% of an infringer's global annual turnover, which is higher than the maximum for the most serious incidents under the EU's Cyber Resilience Act.
Six other laws in the way
The draft also overlaps with six existing EU acts, which the Commission itself lists in Article 4. Where they conflict, the other law wins. To know whether a given mechanic is allowed, a studio has to read the Digital Fairness Act plus six other instruments, then work out which governs.
Large publishers can absorb that. A team of eight in Bordeaux cannot, and this is the argument Supercell's chief executive and several trade bodies have made. The law applies to non-European publishers selling into Europe as well, but enforcement tends to land on companies with addresses and staff inside the bloc. A studio in Milan is easier to fine than a shell with a registered office elsewhere, whatever its monetisation looks like.
Europe has already shown it will legislate against platform behaviour, and the pattern repeats here: a rule aimed at the largest operators, applied to everyone.
The comment window is open
The Commission is taking feedback until January 14. Changes are possible, and adoption is months or years away. But the direction is set, and the studios that start mapping their currencies and purchase flows now will have less to rebuild later.
Small teams that survive on one release have the most to lose from a compliance load that scales with the number of systems rather than revenue. The draft asks them to do what a publisher's legal department would do, with no budget for it, and to prove it in a market where the fine is charged as a share of everything they earn worldwide.