Blizzard changed how dungeon experience works in World of Warcraft: Forever on November 13, then revised the change a day later after normal groups found themselves earning nothing. The original hotfix removed experience from any enemy that counted as trivial to a single member of the party, which in a five-player group meant one over-levelled friend could switch off the rewards for everyone. PC Gamer reported the reversal and the studio's own admission that the fix missed the mark.

The case for the first version

Dungeon boosting has been a paid service in Classic for years: a high-level character clears a run while low-level customers stand at the entrance and collect experience for the walk. It is one of the few ways to buy progress with real money without touching the auction house, and it pushes players out of the open world that the game is built around.

Blizzard's answer was blunt. If an enemy is grey to anyone in the group, nobody gets experience from it. On paper, that ends the market in a single line of code, and it explains why the studio shipped it on a Thursday rather than waiting for a maintenance window.

Why it caught ordinary players

The problem is the level ranges. GameSpot points out that many Forever dungeons span double-digit levels, so an enemy near the entrance can be trivial to a character who is still well inside the recommended band for the final boss. Uldaman runs from 41 to 51 in the dungeon finder, Maraudon from 46 to 55, and the Scarlet Monastery gauntlet covers 30 to 44 in one sweep.

Worse, a player could level up mid-run and turn the next pull grey for themselves, which zeroed the experience for the whole party. Committing two hours to a dungeon and then discovering that nobody is earning anything because you dinged is a social problem, and the complaints arrived fast enough that Blizzard posted a correction within 24 hours.

The compromise is a number

The amended hotfix keeps the mechanic but attaches a threshold: experience is nullified only when the high-level player is more than 12 levels above the enemies in the instance. That clears the boosting case, where the carry is typically decades of levels above the content, and leaves the friend-helping-a-friend case alone. A level 25 character running Deadmines with a group of level 18s still hands out full experience, even though their presence makes the run easier.

Twelve is a judgment call, not a derived figure, and it will be tested by players who find the exact gap where a carry still works. The wider question is the one Forever has been arguing about since beta: how much experience a dungeon should pay relative to questing. Blizzard has said it deliberately keeps friction in the levelling curve, and the first week of the relaunch showed how crowded that curve makes the old zones. Dungeon rewards are the release valve for that crowding. Close the valve too tightly and players who cannot find a quest mob have nowhere to go.